I deal with computers, hence I want things to work the most boring and reliable way possible, with automation, procedures, scripts, not through magic.
Hence, while I love tools such as Atuin, I've a problem with their slogan "Making your shell magical" and generally speaking with any product using such selling argument, especially AI LLM-based products.
For this reason, I'm usually against any kind of black box and one-for-everything tools and platforms that want to ease our lives by hiding the complexities. I think that the only result we get out of those abstractions is complexity, pain, and a culture of incompetence and dependability. I mean, if you want to deal with technology, at least you should understand it.
In the end, it's not all magic [1] [2], but it can feel magic for sure once we lack understanding. Magic feels shiny and appealing after all, its antonyms say it all.
Let encourage everyday users to look inside the box and understand what is happening, even if not everyone is going to switch to Linux, even if debugging is not easy.
At work, there exist an onboarding procedure targeted towards new developers in the team, and this procedure relies on scripts which were left untouched for way too long. The bad things : the procedure is broken but nobody dares to fix it, instead the old timers in the team share dirty hacks and workarounds with the newcomers.
Once you face such problem, the only solution is to address the root causes, not the symptoms. I choose to take a look at the procedure, run it again and again after each attempted improvement, cut it piece by piece, shred or rewrite what seems unreliable and suspicious.
Magic exists, but I’ve never seen any in software. Problems are logical. Nothing is impossible. You can solve this problem.1
As a software engineer, please don't fix symptoms. Don't get too used to deal with crap and unsolved problems. Don't be lazy, don't accept the status quo, make the hard work to understand and solve the problems. Set your focus on understanding things deeper. Enhance your and everyone's knowledge. Be a firefighter against ignorance, and help educate your peers to be better at understanding why things work or doesn't.
Thank you.
- https://catskull.net/thoughts-on-debugging.html ↩︎